Pundits mine Kagan memos to reinforce own views
Depictions of Kagan range from politically ambitious to Clinton loyalist to ho-hum pragmatic moderate
The release of 42,000 pages of memos relating to Supreme Court nominee Elena Kagan’s years in the Clinton White House has provided a kind of Rorschach test in which reporters and commentators can find whatever images suit their own preconceptions.
Kagan served as a deputy White House counsel from 1995 to 1997 and then as a domestic policy adviser until 1999. During those years, the Washington Post proclaims, “she quickly found herself immersed in the scandals and snafus of Bill Clinton’s presidency: the Paula Jones case, Whitewater, and a controversy over mishandled FBI files. … Kagan was taking part in dramas and debates that often were as political in nature as legal — and … she was showing a relish for them.”
“The newly released documents show just how finely tuned Kagan’s political antennae were,” the Post continues, citing such incidents as Kagan’s drafting of an op-ed to be signed by legal experts, arguing that attorney-client privilege protected Clinton’s lawyers from having to divulge information to the Whitewater investigation. Even Kagan’s attempts to secure an administrative assistant when she first arrived in the White House are described as “internal politicking.”
In contrast with the Post’s description of Kagan as involved in a broad range of politically sensitive issues, the Wall Street Journal chose to focus more narrowly on the Paula Jones sexual harassment case against Clinton. The Journal story actually spends several paragraphs detailing Clinton’s unsuccessful effort to have the case dismissed before bothering to note that “an Obama White House aide said Ms. Kagan wasn’t crafting litigation strategy in the Paula Jones case and focused on more routine work such as reviewing documents.”
One Fox News blog makes a similar attempt to associate Kagan with Clinton-era scandals by describing her as “busy coordinating an aggressive media response to the Whitewater scandal that clouded much of the Clinton Administration.”
A very different take on the Kagan memos, however, appears in an associated Press story, which emphasizes Kagan’s involvement in crafting language intended to limit a proposed ban on partial-birth abortion, along with other memos that provide “glimpses of Kagan’s positions on controversial issues, such as her reservations about a federal law banning assisted suicide, and instances where she took a broad view of religious freedom.”
“In one case likely to be cited by her allies as evidence that she’s no liberal,” AP notes, “Kagan criticized a California court for rejecting a landlady’s claim that a state anti-discrimination law violated her religious freedom. in a 1996 memo, Kagan suggested that her appeal should be taken by the Supreme Court and that the justices should side with the landlady, who refused to rent to unmarried couples based on her belief that sex outside of marriage was wrong.”
And perhaps the ultimate image of Kagan as non-partisan and non-controversial appears in a column at Forbes by legal expert Victoria Pynchon, titled “Kagan Documents Show Pragmatism, Inclination to Seek Middle Ground.”
“The documents reveal Kagan’s pragmatic mind-set as well as her willingness to negotiate across partisan and ideological lines,” Pynchon writes. “Kagan’s opinions on the ‘hot button’ issues that have provided the drama in every confirmation hearing since Robert Bork’s do not stray far from those held by Democrats, who tend to possess a far broader range of views than is generally depicted.”
Tags: Elena Kagan
Pundits mine Kagan memos to reinforce own views
Related Websites
- 40,000+ More Documents re: Supreme Court Nominee Elena Kagan Made Available Online « ResourceShelf
- Torture Memos’ John Yoo Greeted at Berkeley by Protesters « The Wild Side
- Bill Clinton Approached Joe Sestak To Drop Senate Bid At White House Request « Has Anyone Ever?
- Sex scandals and Nazi references, it must be election season | College Magazine Blog
- Weasel Zippers » Blog Archive » FBI Files: Walter Cronkite Collaborated With Anti-War Activists…
- New FBI Files Alleging AIPAC Theft of Gov Property and Israeli Espionage Released | We Are Change Utah
- Alison Giroux » Blog Archive » FBI Files – Real Archives of Hollywood Stars and Famous Singers?
- Open Scandal » Mikhail Kryzhanovsky. “Foreign policy secrets”
- New York City News Service – CUNY Graduate School of Journalism » Blog Archive » FBI Files: Helms Faced Threats
- Defense Systems Info » Muslim militants behead 3 Filipino loggers – Washington Post
- NOTORIOUS Video Diary #12: Angela Bassett
- Arsenal Star Andrey Arshavin Would Relish Playing For Barcelona | WORLD-TRACK GLOBAL SITE
- john terry : Off-the-pitch scandals of World Cup | US Post Today.
- Supreme Court Nominee | GEEK!
- Supreme Court Nominee Elena Kagan’s Views just as Opaque as Obama’s | The Post & Email
- The Mudflats | Senator Mark Begich Meets With Supreme Court Nominee Elena Kagan
- Pocketbook 302 review: Preconceptions | TeleRead: Bring the E-Books Home
- Obama to Withold Documents on Supreme Court Nominee That Reveal Liberal Agenda? : Stop The ACLU
- SCOTUSblog » Monday round-up
- Rose Law Group Blog » Blog Archive » Contractors: Highway snafus costing building industry billions annually
Categories: Headlining News Tags: antennae, commentators, elena kagan, preconceptions, scandals, washington post
Do you think sports commentators get paid to just babble?
Don’t you ever get tired of the endless, mindless sports commentary? I bet there is more talk about sports than acutal sports itself.
Related Websites
Categories: Top Sports News Tags: babble, commentators, Just, paid, Sports, Think
Do Liberals understand the difference between the news and news commentators?
Why does it seem like they think Glen Beck & Hannity & Bill O’ Reilly are reporting the news when they are expressing their own opinions?
Related Websites
- How do debt relief companies advertised on Hannity, Limbaugh and Levin work? | Money Matters
- Bill O’Reilly Calls Terrorist’s Lawyer A Weasel « lawyersinmiami.org
- New Video: Huckabee on Hannity | HucksArmy | Grassroots for Gov. Mike Huckabee
- Daily Show – Glen Beck – Awesome – Watch!
- Jon Stewart Destroys Glen Beck on the Daily Show | Popehat
- Bill O’Reilly helps raise cash in Palm Beach for rape victims’ advocates | Jose Lambiet’s Page2Live.com
- Sean Hannity Calls Obama the S-Word | NewsReal Blog
- Bill O’Reilly – Anthony Weiner – Debate Health Care | Mediaite
- Sesame Street Hates Bill Oreilly New Sesame Street Puppet Pokes Fun at Fox and Bill Oreilly | Its My Forum
- Mark Levin and Glen Beck, President and Vice President in 2012? | Its My Forum
- Why is Obama such a whiner about Rush Limbaugh and Sean Hannity? | Its My Forum
- Hannity, bachmann and price use attacks on cantor to attack democrats | George Bush Videos
- Bill O’Reilly Invites Snoop Dogg | Weed Seeds For Sale
- Following the money in Hannity-Freedom Alliance scam – Rick Ungar – The Policy Page – True/Slant
- Beck and Palin are “Special Needs Parents” « Malia Litman's Blog
- Anthony Weiner To Bill O’Reilly – Stop Making Stuff Up
- What Evangelicals can learn from the Glen Beck/Jim Wallis Debate « Christian Theology
- Can anyone find the thing Glen Beck is talking about re: cash for clunkers?
- Dean Brian Baker’s Blog » Colbert is Sacra-brilliant re Glen Beck & Social Justice
Categories: Headlining News Tags: between, commentators, difference, Liberals, News, understand